Ordering Now Available for


Family owned by brothers Brent And Curt Shafer, The Pizzeria has been operating in Putnam County since 1972.

We believe The Pizzeria serves the finest pizza in the area and we are dedicated to offering the freshest and highest quality toppings available.  Our pizza sauce recipe has remained unchanged since 1972 and continues to be a customer favorite.  We also feel that baking our pizzas in traditional deck ovens produce a superior pizza than  the quicker conveyor ovens.  

Brent and Curt can be found in the Pizzeria kitchen on most nights and believe in the "hands on approach".  

It has been a pleasure to become a part of each community.  We have been blessed with a great group of managers and employees at The Pizzeria, both past and present!